Vis tijdens zwangerschap voor gezonde kinderen.*
Kinderen
van moeders die tijdens hun zwangerschap veel vis en schaal en schelpdieren
hebben gegeten, zijn intelligenter. Die kinderen zijn ook beter in staat
allerlei vaardigheden te ontwikkelen dan kinderen waarvan moeders dit niet
hebben gedaan.
Dat blijkt uit een Engels-Amerikaans onderzoek. De onderzoekers noemden de
resultaten donderdag verrassend omdat de nu geldende gedachte is dat vis tijdens
de zwangerschap slecht is voor het ongeboren kind omdat het kwik in vis
schadelijk zou zijn voor de ontwikkeling van het zenuwstelsel. Doch de nadelen
van een eventuele vervuiling zijn klein in verhouding tot de grote voordelen van
de essentiële bestanddelen zoals omega-3 vetzuren die nodig zijn voor de
ontwikkeling van hersenen, aldus onderzoeker Joseph Hibbeln. Het onderzoek
volgde bijna 12.000 Britse vrouwen. Ze werden in drie groepen verdeeld, zij die
nooit vis aten, zij die minder dan 340 gram vis per week aten en zij die 340
gram of meer vis aten per week. Kinderen van moeders die weinig of geen vis aten
tijdens de zwangerschap bleken op 8 jarige leeftijd wel 48% meer kans te hebben
in de groep met de lagere IQ’s te zitten. Verder hadden deze kinderen minder
vaardigheden zowel motorisch als sociaal.
Eating
More Fish During Pregnancy Benefits Child Development
US
and British scientists have shown that children whose mothers ate fish several
times a week while they were pregnant were more likely to have higher scores in
tests of mental and social ability.
The study is published in The Lancet.
The scientists sent questionnaires periodically to 11,875 pregnant women in
Bristol, England who were part of the Avon Longitudinal Study of Parents and
Children (ALSPAC) and whose babies were expected to be born between April 1991
and December 1992.
The mothers were asked questions about their diet during pregnancy and about
their children's mental and social development up to the age of 8.
The researchers noted that "children of mothers who ate small amounts of
seafood were more likely to have suboptimum neurodevelopmental outcomes than
children of mothers who ate more seafood".
Using multivariable logistic regression analysis the researchers compared the
children's developmental, behavioural and cognitive scores against their mothers'
seafood consumption in pregnancy. The mothers' sea food consumption was in three
categories: no seafood consumed, some seafood consumed (up to 340 g per week),
and seafood consumption exceeding 340 g per week.
The analysis took into account and eliminated 28 other factors or confounders
that might have had an impact, such as social disadvantage and dietary habits.
The results showed that where mothers had consumed less than 340 g a week, this
was linked to a significant increased likelihood that their children would be in
the bottom 25 per cent of verbal intelligence quotient (IQ) at age of 8, and to
have "suboptimum performace" on developmental and social behaviour
tests. This was in comparison to children whose mothers ate more than 340 g of
seafood a week.
The study was led by Dr Joseph Hibbeln of the US National Institute of Alcohol
Abuse and Alcoholism. He said that "For the baby's development, at the
level of 12 ounces (340 g) a week during pregnancy, the beneficial effects of
the nutrients in fish far outweigh the risk."
340 g a week (about 12 ounces, equivalent to three servings) is the most seafood
a pregnant woman is advised to eat in the US because of risks associated with
toxic elements such as mercury. This is the advice of the Food and Drug
Adminstration (FDA) and the Environmental Protection Administration (EPA).
The EPA and the FDA are aware of the study and say they have no plans to change
their advice at this stage.
The researchers said they had problems finding a large group of American women
who ate fish several times a week which is why they used the English cohort.
While the study did not look into the reason why maternal fish eating might
confer advantages to the child's development, the researchers speculated that it
might be due to the high levels of omega-3 fatty acids in seafood. These long
chain fatty acids are considered essential for neurological development in
pregnancy and early childhood.
Omega-3 fatty acids are also present in other foods such as hemp seeds, chia
seeds, flax seeds, walnuts, kiwi fruit and eggs from chickens whose diet
includes greens and insects.
"Maternal seafood consumption in pregnancy and neurodevelopmental
outcomes in childhood (ALSPAC study): an observational cohort study."
Joseph R Hibbeln, John M Davis, Colin Steer, Pauline Emmett, Imogen Rogers,
Cathy Williams and Jean Golding.
The Lancet 2007; 369:578-585
DOI:10.1016/S0140-6736(07)60277-3
(Maart 2007) (Opm.
Meer over vis.)